Scientists have long known our brains need sleep to review the day’s events and transfer them into longer-term memories. Students are often told to study just before turning in to maximize their recall of material for a test the next day.
But the exact way in which the brain stores our memories is poorly understood.
Now for the first time, tiny microelectrodes planted inside the brains of two people show just how the brain’s neurons fire during sleep to “replay” our short-term memories in order to move them into more permanent storage. The study was published in the journal Cell Reports.
“This study is fascinating,” said Dr. Richard Isaacson, who directs the Alzheimer’s Prevention Clinic at Weill Cornell Medicine and New York-Presbyterian Hospital.
“Despite decades of research, it remains somewhat unclear how ‘short-term’ memories get filed away to become ‘long-term’ memories that can be recalled later,” Isaacson, who was not involved in the study, said.
“Using a brain-computer interface is an exciting way to study memory since it can record brain cell activity patterns and then look for those exact patterns later,” he added.
Tracking individual neurons
The study was conducted at BrainGate, an academic research consortium composed of Brown University, the Providence VA Medical Center, Massachusetts General Hospital, Stanford University and Case Western Reserve University.
Braingate has spent the last dozen or more years developing brain-computer interfaces that allow people with amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS) and other neurologic diseases, brain injury or limb loss to be able to use their brain signals to move computer cursors, robotic arms and other assistive devices to communicate and control their world.
“Neurons are tiny. They’re about 10 microns in size,” said computational neuroscientist and study author Beata Jarosiewicz. “And the macro electrodes that are approved for human use, such as the deep brain-stimulating electrodes, are too big to record the individual spiking activity of each neuron.”
But at Braingate, surgeons implanted an array of minute electrodes onto the top of the brains of two people with sensory and motor paralysis, thus allowing the person to just “think” about moving their hand in a direction. By mapping the way the neurons behave during thought, the decoder can translate the thought into speech or into action via attached prosthetic limbs and assistive robotic devices.
“Different neurons have different preferred directions,” said Jarosiewicz, who was a research assistant professor at Brown University at the time of the study.
“Some increase their firing rates whenever the person wants to move their hand upwards; others when the person wants to move to the right or left,” she said. “And we can tell by the pattern of activation across all of the neurons which direction the person wants to move their hand.”
Playing Simon Says
In the study, the two people with implanted devices were asked to take a nap in which their neuron activity was recorded as a baseline. Then each played a sequence game modeled after the 1980s hit electronic gameSimon, in which players are asked to repeat the same order of light movements the game had just displayed.
Instead of moving arms to follow Simon, of course, the two people used their minds to repeat the game’s actions while their neural activity was recorded. Finally, the two were asked to rest and nap.
The results showed that duringthose napsthe neuron activity was strongly correlated with activity recorded while the two subjects were actually playing the game. This meant their brains kept playing Simon after they were asleep, replaying the same patterns in their brain at a neuronal level.
“Fully understanding how a memory gets stored in the brain may help unlock secrets to optimal cognitive function,” said Isaacson, who is a trustee of the McKnight Brain Research Foundation, which funds research into novel treatments and prevention of neurological diseases.
The use of such technology to study brain movements during sleep is why “this study is unprecedented,” Jarosiewicz said. “There aren’t a lot of scenarios in which a person would have a multielectrode array placed in their brain, where the electrodes are tiny enough to be able to detect the firing activity of individual neurons.”
The procedure is obviously rare. In fact, Braingate has only implanted 14 such devices in the history of the consortium’s work, Jarosiewicz said.
“This supports the notion that in order to optimize memory function and learning, people need to prioritize restful activities — most importantly adequate sleep — to keep our ‘engines’ running at peak performance,” said Isaacson.
There are some at-home monitoring devices, Isaacson said, such as wrist-worn straps and rings, which claim to track different sleep stages that may be most important for memory consolidation.
Hopefully, he said, “future studies will help clarify which specific stages of sleep — deep sleep, REM sleep— in which memory replay occurs most frequently.”